Plain text vs HTML emails for online stores

When a text-only email beats a designed one in Klaviyo, when it does not, and how the automatic plain-text version of every HTML email actually works.

Manuel Sierra

6 min read

Design and copy
In this article · 7 sections

Use HTML for emails that sell a product: launches, campaigns, abandoned carts, anything where the picture does the work. Use plain text for emails that sound like a person: a founder note, an apology, a reply-style welcome. Neither wins everywhere, and the useful question is not which one converts better but which one fits the job of that email.

Most pages on this search are tool-vendor posts that pick a side. We do not have a verified industry figure that says one format beats the other, so we will not quote one. What follows is what Klaviyo documents, and the rule we use on client accounts.

What the two formats actually are

An HTML email is the designed one: images, buttons, columns, brand fonts. In Klaviyo it is what the drag-and-drop editor produces.

A text-only email is, in Klaviyo's words, one that consists "mainly or entirely of text" with "limited formatting and images". It looks like a message from a person, not a catalog.

There is a third thing that many stores miss. Every HTML email also carries a plain-text version. Klaviyo generates one automatically for every email built in the drag-and-drop editor and sends it alongside the HTML. Some inboxes do not accept HTML, and an inbox may show plain text for security or accessibility reasons. You cannot tell which version a given recipient sees.

So the real choice has two parts: which format is the email, and whether you have looked at the plain-text version of the HTML ones.

When to use each

EmailFormat we chooseWhy
Product launch, new collectionHTMLThe product image is the argument
Campaign with a hero, offer and productsHTMLLayout guides the eye to the button
Abandoned cart, browse abandonmentHTMLThe product they left is the reminder
Founder note in the welcome seriesText onlyKlaviyo itself suggests it for a personal note about your origins
Apology after a mistakeText onlyKlaviyo suggests it for apologies, and design would feel wrong
"Reply and tell us what you need" emailText onlyLooks like a message from a person, which invites a reply
Long story or letterText onlyEasier for screen readers and assistive technology, per Klaviyo
Order and shipping updatesHTML, simpleClear details matter more than polish

This table is our criterion, not a benchmark. Klaviyo documents the text-only cases in rows 4, 5 and 7; the rest is how we work.

Why text only suits a welcome email

Klaviyo lists welcome series messages among the cases where text only works well, and says these emails are often most effective when signed by a team member such as a founder or CEO. That fits how a new subscriber reads. The first emails set the relationship, and a message that looks like a note from a person sets a different tone than a banner.

If you are building the series, welcome emails, structure and examples shows the job of each email. The founder-story email is the natural candidate for text only. Pair it with a real reply-to inbox, as in why noreply addresses cost you sales, or the invitation to reply goes nowhere.

How to send a text-only email in Klaviyo

For a campaign:

  1. Go to Campaigns, click Create campaign, name it and choose Single channel, then Email.
  2. Set recipients and tracking, then enter the subject line and check the sender.
  3. Open the three-dot menu and select "Switch to text only editor."

For a flow, add an Email action, open its three-dot menu, select Edit and choose "Text only." To replace an existing email, use Change template and pick "Text only." That replaces the current content, so copy what you want to keep first.

In the text editor you can add personalization, images, bullet or numbered lists, and limited font and color changes. Klaviyo caps all text-only emails at 1.05 MB. Always send yourself a preview before the real send.

Check the plain-text version of your HTML emails

This is the step most stores skip, and it takes two minutes.

  1. In a campaign, go to the Message step, open Template options (three dots) beside the preview and click "Edit plain text version." In a flow, open the email, open the Actions menu beside Edit and choose the same option.
  2. Read it as a customer would. Does it make sense without images? Are the links labeled? Is the offer still clear?
  3. Fix what is broken and click Save Plain Text.

Two things to know before you edit. After you edit the plain text, Klaviyo stops keeping it in sync with the HTML, so every future change has to be made in two places. And "Auto-Generate Plain Text" restores syncing but discards your manual edits. For most stores, leave it automatic and only edit the emails where the generated version reads badly.

Klaviyo also says a plain-text alternative can help set you apart from spam. We would not lean on that as a fix. If your emails are landing in spam, the causes are elsewhere, and why your emails go to spam walks through them.

How to decide, and how to test it

We do not switch a store to plain text because a blog says to. We pick the email where a person's voice makes sense, usually the founder note in the welcome series or a re-engagement message, send it as text only and compare it with the designed version using A/B testing in Klaviyo. Judge it on what the email is for: replies for a note, revenue per recipient for a campaign.

Keep the rest consistent. A text-only email still needs a clear subject line (our guide to email subject lines for online stores covers it), an honest sender name and a working unsubscribe link.

Sources

Checked on November 12, 2026.

  • Design
  • Klaviyo
  • Plain text

Common questions

Are plain text emails better than HTML?

Neither is better in general. We do not have a verified industry figure that says so. Klaviyo says text-only emails often see higher click rates than fully designed ones, but also that they are not right for every use case. Plain text suits personal messages such as a founder note or an apology. HTML suits emails where products and layout do the selling.

Does Klaviyo send a plain text version of HTML emails?

Yes. Klaviyo automatically generates a plain-text version of every email built in the drag-and-drop editor and sends it alongside the HTML. You can edit it from the Message step of a campaign or from the email in a flow.

How do I make a text-only email in Klaviyo?

In a campaign, open the three-dot menu in the email step and select "Switch to text only editor." In a flow, add an Email action, choose Edit and pick "Text only." Preview and send yourself a test first.

Do plain text emails go to spam less?

Klaviyo says a plain-text alternative can help set you apart from spam, but it does not say that text-only emails reach the inbox more often. Deliverability depends mostly on authentication, list quality and engagement.

Can I add images to a text-only email?

Yes, a few. Klaviyo says text-only emails can contain limited formatting and images. Add an image with its URL and alt text. If the email needs several images, it is probably an HTML email.

Want us to look at your account?

We look at your whole account in a 45-minute call and tell you what we would do first. No strings attached.

Book your free audit
6 min left